The great C.S. thinks that prayer without words is a possibility and even the superior form of prayer (though difficult to achieve):
Karl Barth disagrees:
For many years after my conversion I never used any ready-made forms except the Lord's prayer. In fact, I tried to pray without words at all -- not to verbalise the mental acts. Even in praying for others I tended to avoid avoid their names all together and substituted mental images of them. I still think that prayer without words is best - if one can really achieve it. But now I see that in trying to make it my daily bread I was counting on a greater mental and spiritual strength than I really have. To pray successfully without words one needs to be 'at the top' of one's form. Otherwise the mental acts become merely imaginative or emotional acts - and a fabricated emotion is a miserable affair. C.S. Lewis, Prayer: Letters to Malcolm, #2.
There can hardly be prayer which does not shape indefinite thoughts and words... On the whole, wordless prayer cannot be regarded as true prayer. CD III/4, 111-112.I am thoroughly verbal. I can hardly have a thought without translating it into words. Much less a prayer.
But what about you? Do you ever pray without words?
No comments:
Post a Comment