Monday, December 14, 2009
where the wild things are
Don't take your six year old and his friends to see this movie.
I'm not good at reviewing movies. Perhaps it was amazingly good and I just couldn't tell. It certainly did have some good points... Anyway, here are my thoughts. Take them or leave them.
Because it was based on a little kids' book, I expected it to be made for kids. It wasn't. Not 6 year olds, anyway. They were disturbed or bored by most of it. They were laughing out loud at some of the bits - like the snow ball and dirt fights - but didn't really know what to do when these bits ended badly. At one stage I pulled out my movie tickets to check that it was PG and not M rated.
Overall, it is a movie about the sadness, anger and confusion felt by a boy from a divorced family. His mother is stressed and overworked, his father is absent and his sister is also struggling to cope. Max (the boy) looses it when his mum has another guy over and won't come and see the cubby house he has built. He puts on his wolf suit, yells, bites her and then runs away to where the wild things are. He tells a few fibs and becomes king of the wild things. The wild things are a sad, angry and confused mob who are in the habit of eating their kings when they find out he not capable of solving their problems and making them happy. Max sees in the wild things some of his own dysfunctionality, but he cannot fix their problems. He goes home to his mum who is waiting for him.
The movie offers no magical happy ending for either Max and his family or for the wild things. The only way forward is for everyone to love and be loved and try their best to get on.
The characters were very well drawn. The boy and his mother and sister were painfully believable, and so were the wild things. At points, the drama could have been happening in my lounge room. I think this made it hard for the kids to see. It was obvious they weren't enjoying it.
It felt really long. The kids thought it was the longest movie they had ever seen. It wasn't.
Visually it was good. The animation seemed well done. The scenery was not exactly beautiful, but it matched the story perfectly. I liked how Max's wolf suit was filfthy.
The line of dialogue which stood out as bad was the key line taken from the book: "please don't go, we'll eat you up we love you so." In the book, this line is a favourite. It displays the futile agression of the wild things, and Max's authority over them. He says a firm, no. But in the movie it is almost a romantic croon. Feels wrong.
Overall, I have no idea. It's a thoughtful movie. I found it to be more bearable than most kids movies. Perhaps for the older boys?
Anyone else seen it?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Thanks for your review. Definitely wasn't going to take our 4 year old to it. Was vaguely wondering about our 6 year old though. But definitely won't be taking him either. Good to find out ahead of time. We are still debriefing after Bolt LAST summer!
ReplyDeleteThat's sad that it wasn't a very good experience. It's awful watching stuff with kids and being painfully aware that it's troubling them.
ReplyDeleteIt's a pity you hadn't read more reviews and stuff, because they've all said similar things-- good, interesting take, but not really for kids.
It's always going to be kind of bizarre with Spike Jonze directing (Adaptation, Being John Malkovich), and I can imagine myself feeling a bit frustarted by him not sticking to some of the 'conventions' with this movie. Still, I'll be interested to check it out.
Hope you guys still had an okay time, and that he enjoyed the rest of his mystery tour.
It's weird also how sometimes what you think is troubling doesn't affect your kid, and what doesn't seem troubling to you can really get to them. My little two year old girl struggles with Finding Nemo. It's all a bit frantic, too much yelling, and some scary bits. Yet she is absolutely obsessed with The Wizard of Oz, and watches it a few times a week. Now I love that movie, but there's some really scary stuff in that. My girl doesn't bat an eye at the wicked witch setting fire to the scarecrow, but runs away when she sees Bruce the shark.
ReplyDeleteI did no research at all. My own fault. The rest of the tour was great.
ReplyDeleteIt's been quite a while since I read it but isn't the book more about Max learning to conquer fear (he being afraid of the dark)? I have a vague memory of his being sent to his room without supper because he was too busy playing at being a wolf in his wolf suit to come inside. Maybe I need to reread the book.
ReplyDelete